Tampere University urged to join an academic boycott of Israel – why is the university holding back?
Tampere University participates in research projects that involve Israeli universities as partners. What constitutes institutional cooperation?
Original text: Aliisa Lyly
Graphics: Tatu Vornanen
Translation: Henna Herronen
Artikkeli on luettavissa myös suomeksi.
Israel’s involvement in international scientific cooperation has provoked discussion within the Finnish academic community. The Student Union of Tampere University (Trey), Tampere University Association of Researchers and Teachers (Tatte) and National Union of University Students in Finland (Syl), among others, demand that Tampere University and the Finnish academic community boycott Israeli academic institutions.
In practice, the academic boycott would entail the university withdrawing from ongoing research projects and refraining from all cooperation with higher education institutions in Israel. The statements also call for Finnish universities to take a stand for the exclusion of the State of Israel from EU-funded projects.
The purpose of the boycott is to pressure the State of Israel to end the warfare in Gaza. Among others, the United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry, the human rights organisation Amnesty International, and the International Association of Genocide Scholars IAGS have stated that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza.
”As I see it, being involved in the same EU project does not constitute institutional cooperation.”

Several demonstrations in support of Palestine have taken place at Tampere University in recent years. The international Students for Palestine movement also calls for higher education institutions to implement an academic boycott of Israel.
At present, Tampere University does not publicly boycott Israeli academic institutions. President Keijo Hämäläinen emphasises, however, that the university has no bilateral cooperation agreements with Israel.
“We do not have any institutional cooperation with Israel that involves a commitment to work with a particular partner. There is not a single partnership agreement, nor are any such agreements being promoted”, Hämäläinen tells Visiiri.
There are no active student or researcher exchanges with universities in Israel, either.
Many are still demanding further measures from the university. If the university does not, in practice, cooperate with Israel, why does the matter continue to be a talking point for activists, the student union, and many students alike?
Friction over international projects
The friction between the university administration and those demanding an academic boycott largely stems from international research projects. Tampere University participates in the European Union’s Horizon Europe funding programme. For the 2021–2027 funding period, Horizon Europe has a budget of 93.5 billion euros, which makes the programme a significant part of the international research network.
”I trust that we all share a deep compassion for Palestine.”
Among Horizon Europe’s partners are countries from outside the EU, including Israel. Tampere University is currently involved in research projects that involve Israeli universities as partners.
“As I see it, being involved in the same EU project does not constitute institutional cooperation,” says President Keijo Hämäläinen.
Monitors from the Statewatch and Informationsstelle Militarisrierung groups, which consist of activists, researchers, and journalists, report that the Israeli Defence Force uses drone technology from the Horizon Europe-funded Xtend project for military operations in the Gaza Strip. Tampere University is not involved in the project.
Thousands of researchers at Tampere University work in international environments. Hämäläinen says that it is difficult for the university administration to keep track of what kind of research is being conducted and with which partners. However, he adds that he trusts the ethical judgement of the researchers at the university.
“When our researchers make values-based choices about whom to conduct research with, I trust that we all share a deep compassion for Palestine.”
According to Hämäläinen, the university maintains an active dialogue with its researchers on research ethics.
No legal basis yet
Attitudes towards the war in Gaza are often compared with attitudes towards Russia’s war of aggression in Ukraine. In Finland, universities can rely on guidelines issued by the Ministry of Education and Culture regarding Russian higher education institutions to bar researchers representing Russian institutions from participating in, for example, conferences held on university premises.

Hämäläinen states that there are no equivalent clear guidelines in place for Israel.
“The pressure should be directed at the state leadership. The day the international community concludes that Israel has reached the point where it should be boycotted, we will know the framework in which to operate.”
He summarizes that without guidelines from the Finnish Ministry of Education and Culture, Tampere University has no legal basis on which to join an academic boycott. Hämäläinen does not consider it his right to make a values-based decision to restrict academic freedom in the scientific community.
Read more:
Tuotantolaitos vai sivistyksen kehto – Saako yliopistossa enää olla mitään mieltä? (in Finnish)